ANOTHER ROUND
Acclaimed San Antonio bar The Brooklynite returns for one-night pop-up
The Brooklynite helped usher in San Antonio's craft cocktail revolution.
One of San Antonio’s most visionary bars is coming back, at least for one evening. Former proprietor Jeret Peña has gathered a crew of former bartenders for a pop-up revival of The Brooklynite, held September 3 at Gimme Gimme, 803 S St Mary's St.
Peña says the original idea was a redo of Double Peñatration, a years-ago pop-up with brother Jorel Peña at Diego Galicia’s Mescalaría Mixtli. With Gimme Gimme owner Aaron Peña (no relation) involved, it eventually became a full-blown reunion of The Brooklynite’s alums.
Peña’s Boulevardier Group first debuted the bar in 2012 at 516 Brooklyn Ave., taking over a dive that was known more for its drug trade than its mixed drinks. Peña gave it a refresh with brocade wallpaper and glittering chandeliers, a look that came to define the American craft cocktail revolution.
San Antonio soon became an epicenter of Texas cocktail culture, buoyed by Mark Bohanan’s San Antonio Cocktail Conference, created the same year. But The Brooklynite extended the map nationally, scoring a James Beard semifinalist nod and a StarChefs award.
After the original place closed in 2019, Peña had originally intended to revive it as an intimate 25-seat cocktail lounge. Four months before its debut, the lease was bought out. Though it never returned, its legacy is still felt throughout San Antonio nightlife.

In addition to Aaron Peña, the former employees are a who’s who of Texas nightlife. Hillary Woodhouse is now a partner in Lonesome Rose and Holy Diver. Javi Flores, who drove down from Austin to bartend on weekends, now owns Fat Ice, whose bespoke cubes can be found at several local bars.
Even the non-bartender names now draw headlines. Elizabeth Johnson, now the chef behind Pharm Table, supplied cold-press juice from her fledgling company Crave. Steven Lee Moya, who provided the soundtrack for many Brooklynite nights, currently travels the globe. Pena jokes that he gave him “2013” pricing for the pop-up.
“I’m very proud of everyone who’s come through the door,” says Pena.
The pop-up, which starts at 7 pm, will feature a quartet of The Brooklynite’s greatest hits. While the fourth cocktail is still to be determined, revelers can expect the rummy Como La Flor, the gin-based Love Beat, and The Missionary, made with the former bar’s famous shrubs.
But the temporary revival isn’t about impressing guests. For Peña, who now works at Spec’s, it's about reliving the camaraderie that once made the bar an essential weekend stop.
“It was a great time, period,” he says.

We'll always sing the praises of Benjie's Munch.Benjie's Munch/ Facebook
Even the sliders have oomph at Tycoon Flats.Tycoon Flats/ Facebook