A $5.5 million gap has stalled one of San Antonio's most ambitious developments. McCombs Enterprises has paused its $277 million Jones Avenue project after talks over city financing broke down.
The developer made the announcement November 13 after negotiations over support from the Midtown Tax Increment Reinvestment Zone (TIRZ) failed to yield a deal. McCombs sought roughly $13 million for public improvements and additional financing costs. City staff countered with a cap of $7.5 million.
The dispute boils down to what qualifies as a public benefit. McCombs says its proposed improvements will amount to about $19.8 million, but city staff concluded that some of those expenses didn't meet the standards for reimbursement. TIRZ dollars come from future tax revenue growth within a specific district, and they can only be used toward eligible work.
The city's Planning and Community Development Committee advanced the staff recommendation in October. That vote didn't secure an agreement, and the negotiations that followed went nowhere.
“Across Texas, major cities have long used public-private partnerships to make projects like this possible, financing public infrastructure such as roads, drainage, parking, utilities, sidewalks, and parks through future, incremental tax revenues generated by the developments themselves,” wrote McCombs in a statement. “The finance package we proposed carried no risk to the City; reimbursement would come only from new tax revenue the project created. After nine months of good faith efforts, we were unable to reach an agreement comparable to those supporting similarly ambitious projects in other Texas cities.”
McCombs envisioned Jones Avenue to be a legacy project. Plans called for roughly 300,000 square feet of multifamily housing, more than 60,000 square feet for restaurants, a 33,000-square-foot fitness center, 265,000 square feet of office space, and another 60,000 square feet for shops.
The company and partner Turnbridge Enterprises partnered with some architectural all-stars for the project, including Michael Hsu Office of Architecture, Studio8, and Lake Flato. The retail and hospitality section of the development, featured in an animated walkthrough, included varied facades and lush landscaping that blended with the architecture of its neighbors, the San Antonio Museum of Art (SAMA) and Pearl.
“Thoughtfully scaled and richly layered, Jones Avenue is designed to encourage exploration at every turn,” wrote the planners on the website. “A network of pathways, green spaces, and architectural moments created a natural rhythm and flow, where retail, dining, and cultural experiences are integrated with intention to offer both clarity and discovery.”
In its statement, McCombs said that restaurants and retailers new to San Antonio had already signed on to the project. The company forecasted that it would generate more than $250 million in incremental tax revenue through 2060 for the City of San Antonio and SAISD.
McCombs has not canceled the Jones Avenue project, but it's unclear when and if construction will resume. It also remains to be seen how its decision will affect other near-downtown development. In October, SAMA announced it was seeking $4-5 million in the city’s bond program to help bring it back to the center of its rapidly changing neighborhood with the intention of connecting Jones Avenue with Pearl.